No apparently Gibson will be the second tall this year, not up the ground so much. Schoenmakers may take this role instead.

Keep Hodge, trade Gibson

Mm yeah had Gibbo last year, is he was given a chance(which he probably never will be at hawthorn) he is capable of averaging 90+, often when given free rein he could get a score as high as 150. Shame really. Who does Alistair Clarkson think he is by playing him in a key position, does he have no empathy for SuperCoachs? 

schoey could be a suprise, and then again could be average, still every team needs to have risks.  I think he may play more the running role than Gibson will as Gibson has more of a mans body, and more AFL footy under his belt.  However I also think it will depend on injuries, and if (when) Young comes back into the side too.  Schoeys price is the cheapest of those mentioned, so it probably also depends on your mix of players.